4 California Criminal Law (3d), Pretrial Proceedings

 

I. ARREST

A. In General.

1. [§1] What Constitutes Arrest.

2. [§2] Distinction: Temporary Detention.

3. Who May Arrest.

(a) Peace Officers.

(1) [§3] General Provisions.

(2) [§4] Local Law Enforcement Agency Personnel.

(3) [§5] State Law Enforcement Agency Personnel.

(4) [§6] Other Peace Officers.

(b) Public Officers.

(1) [§7] Local and State Officers.

(2) [§8] Federal Officers.

(c) [§9] Private Persons.

4. [§10] Immunity From Arrest.

5. Effects of Unlawful Arrest.

(a) [§11] Privilege of Arresting Officer.

(b) No Right To Resist.

(1) [§12] In General.

(2) [§13] Crimes Committed by Person Resisting Arrest.

(c) [§14] Remedies of Arrested Person.

B. Arrest by Officer With Warrant.

1. Complaint.

(a) [§15] Statutory Provisions.

(b) [§16] Factual Averments Required.

(c) [§17] Averments Sufficient.

2. [§18] Issuance and Service of Warrant.

3. Content and Form of Warrant.

(a) [§19] Statutory Requirements and Forms.

(b) [§20] Failure To Identify Defendant.

4. [§21] Warrant of Probable Cause for Arrest.

5. [§22] Summons.

6. [§23] Other Process Distinguished.

C. Arrest by Officer Without Warrant.

1. Arrest for Felony.

(a) [§24] Felony Committed.

(b) Probable (Reasonable) Cause.

(1) [§25] Nature of Concept.

(2) [§26] Determining Probable Cause.

(3) [§27] Illustrations: Probable Cause Shown.

(4) [§28] Arrest Within Home.

2. Arrest for Misdemeanor.

(a) Committed in Presence.

(1) [§29] Reasonable Belief.

(2) [§30] Presence Apparent to Senses.

(3) [§31] Intoxication and Motor Vehicles.

(b) Exceptions.

(1) [§32] Domestic Violence.

(2) [§33] Other Exceptions.

(c) [§34] Arrest by Public Officer or Employee.

3. [§35] Arrest of Probationer or Parolee.

D. Mechanics of Arrest.

1. In General.

(a) [§36] Notice of Intention, Authority, and Offense.

(b) [§37] Display of Warrant.

(c) [§38] Arrest in Day or Night.

2. Use of Force.

(a) [§39] Against Arrested Person.

(b) [§40] Breaking into Premises.

3. [§41] Summoning Assistance.

4. [§42] Search Incident to Arrest.

E. Citizen's Arrest.

1. [§43] Grounds.

2. [§44] Mechanics of Arrest.

F. Arrests for Vehicle Offenses.

1. [§45] In General.

2. [§46] Speed Traps.

3. [§47] Bringing Person Before Magistrate.

4. Release on Promise To Appear.

(a) [§48] Citation, Promise, and Release.

(b) [§49] Appearance, Bail Forfeiture, or Trial.

(c) [§50] Failure To Appear.

5. [§51] Promise To Correct Violation.

6. [§52] Notice of Violation in Traffic Accident.

G. Citations for Misdemeanors and Infractions.

1. [§53] In General.

2. [§54] Release on Promise To Appear.

3. [§55] Filing and Bail.

4. [§56] Warrant and Complaint.

5. [§57] Juvenile Offenses.

6. [§58] Reasons for Nonrelease.

H. Steps After Arrest.

1. In General.

(a) [§59] Booking, Fingerprinting, and Photographing.

(b) [§60] Tests for Intoxication or Addiction.

(c) [§61] Notification Concerning Particular Offenses.

2. Rights of Arrested Person.

(a) [§62] In General.

(b) [§63] Telephone Calls.

(c) [§64] Visit by Attorney.

(d) Taking Before Magistrate.

(1) [§65] Nature and Purpose of Requirement.

(2) Promptness: Within 48 Hours.

(aa) [§66] In General.

(bb) [§67] Scope of Requirement.

(cc) [§68] Distinction: Detention of Juveniles.

(3) [§69] Arrest in Another County.

(4) [§70] Complaint in Another County.

(5) [§71] Effect of Delay.

(e) Blood Test for Intoxication.

(1) [§72] Right of Arrested Person.

(2) [§73] Necessity of Proper Request.

3. [§74] Release Without Criminal Charge.

4. Retention, Sealing, and Destruction of Arrest Records.

(a) [§75] No Constitutional Right to Destruction of Records.

(b) [§76] Statutory Provisions.

 

II. BAIL

A. In General.

1. [§77] Nature of Bail.

2. [§78] Purpose of Bail.

3. [§79] California Law.

B. Right to Bail Before Conviction.

1. [§80] Bail as Matter of Right.

2. Exceptions.

(a) Capital Cases.

(1) [§81] No Right to Bail.

(2) [§82] What Constitutes Capital Crime.

(b) [§83] Public Safety.

C. Procedure.

1. Admission to Bail.

(a) [§84] On Arrest.

(b) [§85] After Being Held To Answer.

(c) [§86] After Indictment.

2. Fixing Amount.

(a) [§87] In General.

(b) [§88] Illustrations.

(c) [§89] Increase of Bail.

(d) [§90] Excessive Bail and Reduction.

3. Permissible Types of Bail.

(a) [§91] Undertaking.

(b) [§92] Deposit of Cash, Check, or Money Order.

(c) [§93] Deposit of Government Bonds.

(d) [§94] Equity in Real Property.

4. Exoneration of Bail.

(a) [§95] In General.

(b) [§96] Termination in Defendant's Favor.

(c) [§97] Judgment of Conviction and Commitment to Custody.

(d) [§98] Judgment of Conviction and Probation.

(e) [§99] Arrest and Surrender.

(f) [§100] Recommitment to Custody.

(g) [§101] Other Situations.

5. Effect of Defendant's Failure To Appear.

(a) [§102] Criminal Sanctions.

(b) Forfeiture of Bail.

(1) [§103] Grounds.

(2) [§104] Defenses.

(3) [§105] Timely Declaration and Continuance.

(4) Notice of Forfeiture.

(aa) [§106] In General.

(bb) [§107] Where Original Forfeiture Is Vacated.

(cc) [§108] Appeal Bond.

(5) [§109] Summary Judgment Against Sureties.

(c) Relief From Forfeiture.

(1) [§110] Appearance and Surrender of Defendant.

(2) [§111] Nonappearance Excused.

(3) [§112] Assessment of Costs.

6. [§113] Recommitment of Defendant.

D. Release on Own Recognizance.

1. [§114] In General.

2. [§115] Hearing.

3. [§116] Agreement and Conditions.

 

III. PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION

A. In General.

1. [§117] Nature and Purpose.

2. [§118] Guilt or Innocence Not Determined.

3. [§119] Where Examination Is Not Required.

4. Waiver of Right to Examination.

(a) [§120] Without Plea of Guilty.

(b) [§121] By Plea of Guilty or Nolo Contendere.

B. Right to Counsel.

1. [§122] Opportunity To Obtain Chosen Counsel.

2. [§123] Right to Appointment of Counsel.

3. [§124] Mandatory Representation in Capital Case.

4. [§125] When Waiver of Counsel Is Authorized.

5. [§126] Ineffective Waiver.

6. [§127] Self-Representation.

C. Time for Hearing.

1. [§128] Two Days To Prepare.

2. [§129] Statutory Time Limit.

3. [§130] Effect of Delay Beyond Limit.

4. [§131] Continuance as to Fewer Than All Defendants.

5. [§132] Review of Delay Beyond Limit.

6. [§133] Postponement.

D. Attendance at Hearing.

1. [§134] Presence of Defendant.

2. [§135] Exclusion and Separation of Witnesses.

3. Exclusion of Unauthorized Persons.

(a) [§136] At Defendant's Request.

(b) [§137] On Prosecutor's Motion.

(c) [§138] Admission of Victim's Family.

4. Attendant To Support Prosecuting Witness.

(a) [§139] In General.

(b) [§140] Statute Constitutional.

E. Evidence.

1. [§141] In General.

2. Admissibility of Hearsay.

(a) [§142] When Permitted.

(b) [§143] Double Hearsay Prohibited.

3. Evidence for Defense.

(a) [§144] Earlier Cases.

(b) [§145] Current Restrictions.

F. Determination.

1. [§146] Ruling on Demurrer.

2. [§147] Sufficiency of Showing.

3. Holding Defendant To Answer.

(a) [§148] In General.

(b) [§149] Transcript.

4. [§150] Reducing Charge to Misdemeanor.

5. Dismissal and Discharge.

(a) [§151] Order of Discharge.

(b) Motion To Reinstate Complaint.

(1) [§152] Statutory Provision.

(2) [§153] Scope of Statute.

 

IV. ACCUSATORY PLEADING

A. [§154] Nature and Types.

B. Indictment by Grand Jury.

1. [§155] Convening of Grand Jury.

2. Secrecy of Proceedings.

(a) [§156] General Policy.

(a-1) [§156A] (New) Ancillary Proceedings in Superior Court.

(b) [§157] Exclusion of Unauthorized Persons.

(c) [§158] Effect of Presence of Unauthorized Persons.

(d) [§159] Authorized Disclosures.

(e) [§160] Public Sessions on Official Misconduct.

3. [§161] Witnesses.

3A. [§161A] (New) Subpena Duces Tecum.

4. Evidence.

(a) [§162] Competency.

(b) [§163] Sufficiency.

(c) [§164] Exculpatory Evidence.

5. Indictment and Subsequent Proceedings.

(a) [§165] Finding.

(b) [§166] Presentment and Warrant.

(c) [§167] Transcript to Defendant.

(d) [§168] No Postindictment Preliminary Hearing.

C. Information by District Attorney.

1. [§169] Nature and Requisites.

2. [§170] Procedure.

3. Offense Named or Related Offenses.

(a) [§171] Statutory Rule.

(b) [§172] Modified Rule.

(c) [§173] Illustrations of Proper Charges.

(d) [§174] Improper Charge of Unrelated Offense.

(e) [§175] Renewal of Charges Dismissed by Magistrate.

D. Form and Content.

1. [§176] Formal Parts.

2. [§177] Requisites of Due Process.

3. Liberal Rules.

(a) [§178] Simplified Pleading.

(b) Allegations in Statutory Language.

(1) [§179] Statutory Language Sufficient.

(2) [§180] Statutory Language Insufficient.

(c) [§181] Any Words Giving Notice.

(d) [§182] Designation of Statute by Number.

4. Illustrations of Simplified Pleading.

(a) [§183] Theft.

(b) [§184] Murder and Manslaughter.

(c) [§185] Felonious Assault.

(d) [§186] Robbery and Kidnaping for Robbery.

(e) [§187] Conspiracy.

(f) [§188] Other Offenses.

5. Nonprejudicial Defects.

(a) [§189] Doctrine of Nonprejudicial Error.

(b) [§190] Clerical Error or Surplusage.

(c) [§191] Immaterial Variance.

(d) Time of Offense.

(1) [§192] General Rule.

(2) [§193] Separate Incidents Involved.

(e) [§194] Victim.

(f) [§195] Place.

(g) [§196] Property.

6. Matters Unnecessary To Plead.

(a) [§197] In General.

(b) [§198] Manner or Means of Committing Offense.

(c) [§199] Intent and Knowledge.

(d) [§200] Degree of Crime.

(e) [§201] Aiding and Abetting.

7. Statutory Exceptions.

(a) [§202] In General.

(b) [§203] When Element of Crime.

8. [§204] Timely Prosecution or Excuse.

9. [§205] Prior Conviction.

10. [§206] Serious Felony.

E. Joinder of Offenses in Separate Counts.

1. [§207] In General.

2. [§208] Crimes Connected.

3. [§209] Same Offense Differently Stated.

4. [§210] Same Class.

5. [§211] Multiple Bases for Joinder.

F. Amendment of Accusatory Pleading.

1. [§212] Authority To Amend.

2. Procedure.

(a) [§213] In General.

(b) [§214] Rearraignment and Plea.

(c) [§215] Continuance.

3. [§216] Improper Amendments.

4. Permissible Amendments.

(a) [§217] In General.

(b) [§218] Different or Additional Offenses.

(c) [§219] Minor Defects.

G. [§220] Complaint in Misdemeanor and Infraction Cases.

 

V. ARRAIGNMENT

A. In General.

1. [§221] Nature of Proceeding.

2. [§222] Time and Place.

3. [§223] Presence of Defendant.

B. Right to Counsel.

1. [§224] In General.

2. [§225] Sufficiency of Advice About Right.

C. Proceedings on Arraignment.

1. [§226] In General.

2. [§227] Determining Probable Cause in Misdemeanor Case.

 

VI. ATTACK ON DEFECTIVE INDICTMENT OR INFORMATION

A. Motion To Set Aside.

1. [§228] Nature of Motion.

2. [§229] Indictment: Procedural Defects.

3. Information: Defendant Not Legally Committed.

(a) [§230] In General.

(b) [§231] Rulings on Evidence.

4. Indictment or Information: Lack of Evidence.

(a) [§232] No Reasonable Cause.

(b) [§233] Illustrations.

(c) [§234] Distinctions.

5. Indictment of Information: Nonstatutory Grounds.

(a) [§235] Grant of Immunity.

(b) [§236] Discriminatory Prosecution.

(c) [§237] Statute of Limitations.

(d) [§238] Other Grounds.

6. Procedure.

(a) [§239] In General.

(b) [§240] Information: Correction of Minor or Technical Errors.

7. [§241] Waiver by Failure To Move.

B. Writ of Prohibition.

1. [§242] In General.

2. Lack of Evidence.

(a) [§243] Nature of Ground.

(b) [§244] Procedure.

(c) [§245] Illustrations: Prohibition Granted.

(d) [§246] Illustrations: Prohibition Denied.

C. Demurrer.

1. [§247] Nature of Pleading.

2. Grounds.

(a) [§248] Fundamental Defects.

(b) [§249] Uncertainty.

(c) [§250] Misjoinder.

3. [§251] Form and Procedure.

4. [§252] Waiver by Failure To Demur.

 

VII. PLEA

A. The Statutory Pleas.

1. [§253] In General.

2. [§254] Not Guilty.

3. Former Judgment or Jeopardy.

(a) [§255] Necessity of Special Plea.

(b) [§256] Form of Plea.

4. Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity.

(a) [§257] Necessity of Special Plea.

(b) [§258] Single or Double Plea.

5. [§259] Guilty.

6. [§260] Nolo Contendere.

B. Procedure in Entering Plea.

1. [§261] Time and Form.

2. [§262] Plea by Defendant or Counsel.

3. [§263] Necessity of Counsel.

4. [§264] Refusal or Failure To Enter Plea.

5. Vehicle Offenses.

(a) [§265] Plea on Request.

(b) [§266] Consolidated Pleas.

(c) [§267] Plea Options for Infractions.

C. Requirements for Valid Plea.

1. Felony Cases (Boykin-Tahl Requirements).

(a) [§268] Federal Rule: Intelligent and Voluntary Waiver of Rights.

(b) [§269] California Rule: Express Advice and Waiver of Rights.

(c) [§270] Nature and Scope of Requirements.

(d) [§271] Illustrative Cases.

2. Misdemeanor Cases.

(a) [§272] In General.

(b) [§273] Illustrative Cases.

3. [§274] Infraction Cases.

4. Admonitions Required.

(a) [§275] Advice on Nature of Charge.

(b) Advice on Prior Convictions.

(1) [§276] In General.

(2) [§277] Words Used.

(3) [§278] Illustrations.

(c) Advice on Consequences of Plea.

(1) [§279] Direct Consequences.

(2) [§280] Collateral Consequences.

(3) [§281] Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity Plea.

(4) [§282] Sentencing.

5. [§283] Deportation or Denial of Naturalization of Aliens.

D. Change of Plea.

1. [§284] Addition of Insanity Plea.

2. [§285] Withdrawal of Insanity Plea.

3. Withdrawal of Not Guilty Plea.

(a) [§286] In General.

(b) [§287] Discretion of Court.

4. Withdrawal of Guilty Plea.

(a) Motion.

(1) [§288] In General.

(2) [§289] Before Judgment.

(b) [§290] Showing Required.

(c) [§291] Discretion To Grant or Deny.

(d) [§292] Abuse of Discretion.

(e) Reliance on Official Promises as Basis.

(1) [§293] In General.

(2) [§294] Mistaken Expectation Without Inducement.

(f) Ineffective Representation as Basis.

(1) [§295] In General.

(2) [§296] Advice Against Accepting Plea Bargain.

(3) [§297] Misjudgment or Failure To Anticipate Change in Law.

(4) [§298] Conflict of Interest.

(g) [§299] Effect of Delay or Prior Denial.

(h) [§300] Effect of Granting Motion.

(i) [§301] No Reconsideration When Motion Granted.

(j) [§302] Review of Denial.

 

VIII. PLEA BARGAINING

A. In General.

1. [§303] Nature of Plea Bargain.

2. [§304] Judicial and Statutory Recognition.

3. [§305] Participation by Judge.

4. Consent of Prosecutor.

(a) [§306] In General.

(b) [§307] Separation of Powers Doctrine.

B. Limitations.

1. [§308] In General.

2. [§309] Scope and Effect.

C. Specific Types of Plea Bargains.

1. [§310] Plea to Related Lesser Offense.

2. [§311] Hybrid Plea.

3. Plea Specifying Degree.

(a) [§312] In General.

(b) [§313] Withdrawal.

4. Plea Specifying Punishment.

(a) [§314] In General.

(b) [§315] Factual Basis for Plea.

(c) Right To Withdraw Plea When Court Withdraws Approval.

(1) [§316] In General.

(2) [§317] When Defendant Fails To Appear.

5. [§318] Package-Deal Plea Bargain.

6. [§319] Plea Coupled With Claim of Innocence.

7. [§320] Restitution on Dismissed Charge.

D. Record of Agreement.

1. [§321] In General.

2. [§322] Knowledge of Rights.

E. [§323] Proper Judge.

F. Refusal To Accept Bargain.

1. [§324] In General.

2. [§325] Prosecutorial Vindictiveness.

G. Relief From Bargain.

1. [§326] Change in Maximum Penalty.

2. [§327] Decriminalization of Conduct.

3. [§328] Impossibility of Performance.

4. [§329] Revival of Charges.

5. [§330] Modification of Probation.

6. [§331] Misadvisement.

7. [§331A] (New) Impremissble Conditions.

H. Court's Power To Set Aside Guilty or Nolo Contendere Plea.

1. [§332] Plea Properly Set Aside.

2. [§333] Plea Improperly Set Aside.

I. Nonperformance of Bargain.

1. By Prosecutor or Judge.

(a) [§334] Vacation of Judgment and Withdrawal of Plea.

(b) [§335] Modification of Judgment.

(c) Specific Performance.

(1) [§336] Nature of Remedy.

(2) [§337] Remedy Available.

(3) [§338] Remedy Not Available.

(d) [§339] Withdrawal by Prosecution.

2. [§340] By Defendant.

IX. DEFERRED ENTRY OF JUDGMENT (DIVERSION) AND OTHER SPECIAL PROGRAMS

A. Substance Abuse.

1. [§341] Nature and Purpose.

2. Eligibility.

(a) [§342] Offenses and Conditions.

(b) [§343] Construction of Statute.

(c) [§344] Effect of Other Pending Charges.

(d) [§345] Mandatory Application for Misdemeanor Possession of Marijuana.

(e) [§346] No Diversion After Trial.

3. [§347] Statement From Prosecuting Attorney.

4. [§348] Request by Defendant.

5. [§349] Reference to Probation Department.

6. [§350] Hearing and Determination.

7. [§351] No Waiver by Making Pretrial Motions.

8. [§352] Review of Determination.

9. [§353] Defendant's Satisfactory Performance.

10. [§354] Reinstitution of Criminal Proceedings.

B. [§355] Community Conflict Resolution Program.

C. [§356] Other Programs.

D. [§357] Fees.